To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
My Wife: "This product was surprisingly disappointing. I'm not sure if it was a bad batch or not, because Maybelline has never failed me before...but the eyeliner barely worked, it wasn't bold at all. The line itself was just a smudge." 😏
This eyeliner was dried out after only a few uses. I may have gotten 3 applications out of it,and now it barely covers one eye before its too dried out to do the other. And I dont ha e big thick liner!
Arrived almost completely dried out. I was only able to line 1 eye before the tip stopped dispensing product. I tried to get the flow to restart in any way I could, but it just would not come out. The product is easy to use, and was very black on the one eye I could get it to work on, but i wouldn't recommend buying this unless you only want 1 or 2 uses out of it.
This is the first amazon review I've ever wrote - so you know I'm serious when I say do not buy this if you are looking for waterproof eyeliner. I love everything about this eyeliner besides the fact that it is not waterproof when it claims to be. If I even lay on my side my eyes will start watering so waterproof is very important to me or I will not buy it. Very annoyed since I wasted my money on something that specifically claims to be waterproof and isn't.
The pen is great, I had no smudging issues and my overly teary eyes did not ruin it. I gave this 1 star because after two uses the ink ran out...maybe it was expired? The tip hardened and dried mdespite being capped properly...I was very disappointed.
This is my third time using it, I did one eye and I’ve tried everything to shake it to finish my other eye and it’s completely dried out. What a total waste of money! Also, I Ride a motorcycle and every time I go to take my helmet off the whole side wing smudges right off. Pure garbage.
Its pretty bad. If you have oily eye lids, just don't bother buying, if you DONT have oily lids, still dont bother buying it. It will come off in couple of hours. The tiniest water from your eye will smudge it. Well, it will come off, water or no water tbh.
Saw good reviews about this product, and decided to give it a try. Might have used it twice, smudged the second time. It dint work at at the 3 rd time. Totally dried out. Was mine defective not sure. But even if it had worked, there are better products. Dont waste your money on this.