To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Pros : 1. The brush tip works best for precision liner into the inner rim and corner of the eyes 2. Safe formula for sensitive eyes 3. No smudge
Con 1. The biggest issue is the formula with low color pigmentation that requires 2-3 strokes for result of dull black 2. Uneven Liquid distribution 3. Small diameter that nullifies the holding feature of hexagonal pen . Silly . 50% bigger will be perfect . 4. Water-proof is doubtful as color starts to fade within few hours in the corner of the eyes .
I do not recommend you to buy this pen instead of NYX Vinyl at 4.5$ or NYX epic liner at the same price range . FOr maybelline for eyes , here are the exceptional quality : Tattoo studio gel pencil ( 920 striking navy ) mircro fiber eyebrow mascara Unstoppable eye liner in dark blue
Not really worth the $10 price tag, i got this in pitch black but its not super pigmented. The brush tip was nice but the product comes out so dry that it's really not worth it. I thought this was the north american equivalent to the asian hyper sharp but these two aren't really comparable.
This was great when I first got it. After 2 weeks it seems to be empty already. I started storing it tip down and I'd get one eye done and no more came out. Now none comes out and I haven't even had it 3 weeks!!
I'm editing my review to reflect my new opinions on this eyeliner. At first, I believed that my eyeliner had been dried out a bit, and was not coming out as liquid as I normally like. However, this was just because the eyeliner was new, and hadn't quite been broken in yet. This eyeliner flows beautifully, with just enough product coming out to minimize large pools. The tip creates beautifully sharp points and can be applied for more natural looks as well. It does drag on my eyes slightly, but this might be because I don't use eye primer, and it's nothing that cannot be fixed. This product will create a beautiful cat eye every time, and I will be purchasing it again.
Theres pros and cons to this liner depending what you like/need: -Cons: doesnt smudge but it definitely just completely flakes off when your eyes water. personally found the tip a bit too small, but maybe depends on your eye size/shape -Pros: The liner flows out really nicely and is very black. Also because of the brush tip (instead of felt tip) youre able to get a really fine point. I personally found it was too hard for me to control since my hands are a bit shaky, so Ill just stick with felt tips liners. As well as my eyes are very watery so since this cant hold up to watery eyes its a hard pass for me.
I wish tried it sooner so I could return it but I’m 5 days late . Oh well. Save your money and buy a different liner. Maybe I got a dud who knows but my liner was super patchy/dry. I do like the feel of the pen in my hand it’s quite comfortable but the formula itself was a flop.