I'll start by saying I'm a HUGE TWI HARD. However, at times I found reading this hard going. Mainly because it was soooo detailed and like the majority of those who love the Twilight books, I read the original first 12 chapter draft of Midnight Sun, when Stephenie Myers released it and of course know the Twilight story line backwards. I gave it 5 stars because it was well written and added more to Edwards and the Cullens point of view. The last few chapters when James [The Tracker] appeared, I found actually quite exciting [even though I knew the outcome]. I'm very glad that Stephenie gave her fans what we've been waiting for. It's great to go back into the Twilight world again.