Top rated in Mascara

Compare the most helpful customer reviews of the best rated products in our Mascara shop. These products are shortlisted based on the overall star rating and the number of customer reviews received by each product in the shop, and are refreshed regularly.

Top rated products in Mascara

product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.4 | 48 customer ratings
85% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Love it, my favourite doesn’t
        Read more
By Jacquie
The actual result is 5 stars but Maybelline is not cruelty free, which I wish I’d known before purchasing this mascara. I’m very impressed with how it applies, lengthens and adds volume to my lashes but steer clear if you don’t want to support animal testing. Another website recommended Wet n Wild mascara as an alternative which I
        Read more
By Jazmyn Beattie
Didn't give the results I
        Read more
By saad s.
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
5.0 | 6 customer ratings
100% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Best for long eyelashes that look so
        Read more
By kerry robinson
Love it.It's my every day
        Read more
By Sarah nazzari
Love this
        Read more
By Lorraine D
4.6 | 8 customer ratings
86% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
By nikita
Came in perfect condition and faster than expected. Overall good product
        Read more
By chicken
Dry mascara. waste of
        Read more
By glynis tudor
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.4 | 10 customer ratings
87% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Blends in well, great
        Read more
By V
I found the product easy to use and would recommend
        Read more
By Julie Fasanella
Initially I tried this a few times underneath the Maybelline Lash Sensational Waterproof, created really good volume. However, due to it (I assume not being waterproof) and I have watery eyes, pretty much 60% of the mascara came off. It flaked all over my cheeks and there was barely any mascara left. For that reason I find this pretty
        Read more
By Naomi
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.3 | 12 customer ratings
75% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Provides a gentle, natural enhancement to your eyelashes and extends their length. Soft and not clumpy, easy to remove. Not a mascara if you're needing "thicker"
        Read more
By Paula
Excellent Mascara doesn't feel heavy on lashes and doesn't irritate my eyes, lovely to
        Read more
By Pruedence Corr
Ok for everyday but not wow amazing lashes. Formula is a bit too
        Read more
By Jen
1 offer from product price
4.5 | 7 customer ratings
100% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
very
        Read more
By Jodie
It's okay, good for seperating lashes but has a strong chemical smell which is super off
        Read more
By Casey
The mascara itself is great! However the packaging and bottle have a very strong bad smell which is difficult to get rid of on the mascara
        Read more
By Maddison
4.1 | 25 customer ratings
76% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
This mascara gives you super volume yet fluttery lashes and never flakes or smudges!! This is the third time I’ve bought this one, it’s better than all high end mascaras for
        Read more
By Emma Thomson
This mascara is a pleasure to apply and gives unreal results! Longer thicker lashes. Wipes the floor with more expensive brands...believe me Ive tried them
        Read more
By alibearoz
This seems to be the waterproof version (although it doesn’t say that anywhere), since it doesn’t come off easily like the regular one. I’ve been buying this mascara for a few years now, and love it, but this is different and not for me. As a waterproof mascara, I’d say it’s brilliant, it hasn’t been dry clumpy or flaky for
        Read more
By Nina
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.1 | 14 customer ratings
85% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
No clumping. Easy to use and nice end
        Read more
By Karyn
Great service and product thank you
        Read more
By Jasmina
NICE CONSISTENCY GOOD DARK BROWN
        Read more
By Purple Gurrrl
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.1 | 10 customer ratings
66% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Maybelline products especially mascaras are great for eyes. I hate to see 'clumping' and lashes joined together - you can put a light coat on first and them add volume my reapplying. I love their
        Read more
By helen mature age Aussie
By tammy horn
I find sussing out the best Mascara quite difficult these days. They all claim to make your eye lashes look Colossal, Volumized and miles long. This one is just ordinary in my opinion. It was cheap so I am not complaining but had I paid full price, I would not have been happy. Had to put some 'eye drops' in it, it was so thick and
        Read more
By Heather Tailor
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.2 | 5 customer ratings
74% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Perfect mascara for me. Makes my lashes voluminous and thick without
        Read more
By Amazon Customer
It separates lashes but it also crumbles and is a pain to remove. Unfortunately I think you have to spend a fair bit more to get a really great
        Read more
By Aggie
I was a little disappointed with this mascara, after a couple of hours wearing it I had black under my eyes. I tried sticking with it for a few weeks but it just didn’t work for
        Read more
By Amazon Customer
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.1 | 6 customer ratings
77% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
This is one of the best mascara I've ever used. I don't have natural curly eyelashes, so I need to curl it first before applying mascara. This one is so light and it doesn't push my eyelashes down. The texture of the mascara is very smooth and it creates very natural look instead of giving you "fly-legs". I will definitely stick with
        Read more
By Charles A
Goes on thick, lasts for hours, really brings out the lashes, love
        Read more
By SD
I found that I am allergic to this mascara. I am not sure if this product is
        Read more
By Linda-Anne Relph
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
4.0 | 6 customer ratings
69% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I have tried so many brow gels expensive and cheap because it’s the only brow product I use. This one is by far the best it really glues the hairs in place. It gives a soap brow look but doesn’t flatten the hairs against your skin and doesn’t have visible residue on your brows. I buy it in
        Read more
By Phoebe
Great. Love how quick and easy, and doesn’t
        Read more
By Rubherduckie
I thought I was buying clear mascara for eyelashes, so my fault but the product is still pretty
        Read more
By Lauren Male
3.8 | 8 customer ratings
70% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I love this mascara! The brush allows you to get right to the base of the lashes. I always give my lashes a bit of a curl with my eyelasher curler before applying mascara. I'm totally converted to this mascara and will be buying it
        Read more
By Lisa Shacklock
This is a really nice mascara. Not sure about the falsies push up, but the mascara works like any good mascara, and washes off very easily with
        Read more
By Happy
I don't like waterproof mascara as it's really hard to removeThis mascara is very easy to remove and also stays without flakes around my eyes for a reasonable time for a dayIt has a small comb type of brush which is so good for untangling my messy eyelashesoverall, i will continue to use
        Read more
By Amazon Customer
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
3.8 | 6 customer ratings
77% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Love this mascara and such a great price on Amazon. The only downfall is that it is hard to remove at night and you must use an eye makeup remover but this means it stays on all day and doesn’t leave transfer marks on your
        Read more
By Miranda
By cheryl-in-oz
By M Vallance
product price FREE Delivery on first order. Details
3.7 | 9 customer ratings
54% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Item as described and fast
        Read more
By RIESKA APRILLIA
The best waterproof mascara I have ever worn. Thoroughly recommend this
        Read more
By Judi Williams
When I opened the tube, and started using it, it immediately formed clumps and was dry. I gave it a few more goes for a week but it gave me the same clumpy, spidery lashes even with one coat, and removing excess on a tissue.That’s not it, the spoolie is too big and pokey. I hurt my eye everytime I used it. Doesn’t help that the
        Read more
By Herika Manaligod