To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
That comment could be applied to both the authoress and her 'heroine'.
The story line is unbelievable and there is no real mystery for very long because you have to be dozing not to have guessed what is going on half-way into the tale - which is a good job because the so-called detective is more concerned with her clothes, hairdo, deck games and drinks/meals than she is at solving mysteries.
What really grates, however, is not that this just another 'fab young girl' tale, but that the research is truly awful, and if there was any editorial involvement I do wonder where, because there are quite a few non sequiturs.
Research: quite a few characters speak French - but they generally don't do it well, because they have the ability of 'that idiot who thinks he can speak French'. Can the author be so idle that she cannot type the French and German language into a language app. to have it checked? There are so many schoolgirl howlers that it makes one cringe. And are we to believe that a second class passenger had no access at all on an Atlantic crossing ship of this class to a bath during her whole voyage? If so, something should have been made of it.
Editorial - did anyone read this? At one point the 'heroine' sits down at the bar, then 2 pages later she is still on her feet and sits down again. In another chapter she and her sidekick go to lunch in the 2nd class restaurant - despite the fact that (in order to allow the heroine to dine with the other passengers she is interacting with) 1st and 2nd class passengers are dining together on this voyage in the 1st class restaurant, so the 2nd class one cannot be open, surely - albeit that2nd and 1st dining together is not to be believed anyway, and is clearly contrived to allow the heroine to travel 2nd and yet dine in 1st. Nonsense.
It might also have been interesting to learn how the shipping line obtained so much gourmet food when the ship originated in France and passed through England, neither of which was at that time awash in food at all.
With a bit more intelligence and research this could have been a reasonable, average read, if nowhere near the Agatha Christie class. A missed opportunity to my mind.
Please don't write any more like this - I might buy one by mistake, like this one.